Facts and myths
Myths 1
There is a lack of control over the production of beef.
Myths 2
Polish beef of unknown origin is sold to the European Union
Myths 3
Polish beef is worse than foreign beef.
Myths 4
In Poland, there is no concern for the welfare of cattle.
Myths 5
Thanks to the Mercosur trade agreement, Poland will obtain better South American meat.
Myths 6
The meat that ends up on the tables is full of chemistry.
Myths 7
Beef production is the most harmful to the environment.
Myths 8
Sick cattle are also sent to the slaughterhouse.
Myths 9
The irregularities detected in one of the slaughterhouses at the beginning of 2019 are common in the Polish sector
Myths 10
Only Polish producers break the law.
FACTS:

The EU Commission Regulation (EC) No 1828/2006 imposes an obligation on Polish and European beef producers to require certificates of competence from their employees. In addition, the same act prohibits the killing of animals without prior stunning performed in such a way as to minimise the pain of the animal. Polish producers are also covered by national law, which strictly prohibits the slaughter of cattle outside a slaughterhouse when the animal is healthy but has been involved in an accident. In this case, a certificate from the veterinarian responsible and the owner of the injured animal is required and the meat itself is re-examined before it is placed on the market.

In accordance with the Act of 29 June 2007 on the organisation of breeding and reproduction of farm animals, cattle are monitored, among others, by a system of individually numbered ear tags. This rule excludes cows that have not undergone veterinary checks from the slaughterhouse. The solutions being prepared by the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development are to extend supervision to include the obligation to invalidate the passport of an animal which has died or has been killed by order of the Veterinary Inspection within the next few days. The Ministry is also working on the introduction of subcutaneous chips based on Blockchain technology. The device will collect all information about the animal from birth to slaughter. Consideration is also being given to increasing penalties for breaching the rules. The introduction of the proposed amendments to the regulations will completely exclude from the market meat without checks carried out at various stages of production.

Within the EU, the same legislation applies to breeders and producers. In practice, this means adapting the stage of breeding and slaughtering animals to the required EU standards. The taste and quality of our meat was appreciated by consumers from Italy, Germany, France and Great Britain. These countries are the leaders in the import of Polish beef. In order to improve the quality of beef production, the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development is working on an amendment to Polish law, which will force producers to raise already high breeding standards. One of the proposed changes is the introduction of 24-hour monitoring in slaughterhouses. The regulation being developed will allow to exclude any actions which are not in compliance with the regulations. As a result, consumers can be sure that only meat of the highest quality will be released to the market.

In accordance with applicable national and EU law, slaughter without prior stunning of the animal is prohibited. At the same time, farmers and producers must avoid fatigue in cattle in the event of injuries such as fractures. The breeding is under constant supervision of a veterinarian. The general trend shows a high and growing concern for the welfare of cattle, and individual breaches of the rules are immediately criticised by the industry. One of the key elements of concern regarding animal welfare is the issue of animal transport. In accordance with the provisions of Council Regulation (EC) No. 1/2005, cattle must be transported in a manner that does not cause injury, suffering or fall. Trucks must be adequately equipped with, among other things, automatic drinking troughs, sufficiently high cages and loading ramps. In addition, where loading and unloading lasts more than four hours, the animals must have access to food and water. It is also recommended to drive calmly and to calculate a route combining short distance with no sharp corners.

Mercosur is an economic organisation founded in South America. The group includes Brazil, Argentina and Paraguay. The trade agreement concluded between the European Union and the Mercosur countries concerns duty-free quotas for local meat, which is to be placed on the EU market. The greatest controversy among the representatives of all meat industries is related to the regulations applied in the local countries. According to the 2018 audit report of the European Commission’s experts, substances banned by EU law are permitted in cattle breeding in Brazil. Moreover, South American cows, unlike Polish cows, are not obliged to have registers of substances administered at the breeding stage, which makes it impossible for veterinarians to diagnose animals effectively. Clear differences in the standards of breeding and production of beef may be dangerous for consumers looking in shops for products of the highest quality, guaranteed by reliable controls and strict legal regulations.

Article 27 of the Act on the protection of animals directly indicates that medical and veterinary treatments are acceptable for saving life or health. The same legal act determines who may undertake treatment of cattle in breeding – legally it is done only by a person with appropriate qualifications, who will perform the treatment in such a way as to reduce the suffering and stress of the animal. Article 16 of the Act on Products of Animal Origin extends the requirements for producers to include a total ban on the release of beef with even trace amounts of medicinal products on the market. If an animal not meeting this condition is slaughtered, the farmer is not entitled to any compensation. Not only cattle, but also drinking water and feed are tested for their medication content.

Numerous quasi-environmental organisations are currently trying to convince consumers that 15,000 litres of water are needed to produce 1 kg of meat. In fact, more than 90% of the water consumed by livestock is “green water” from precipitation. Scientists calculate that the production of 1 kg of beef actually consumes up to a maximum of 50 litres of fresh water.

Contrary to popular belief, beef production is responsible only for a very small fraction of greenhouse gas emissions. According to FAO statistics in the EU, enteric fermentation from the animal husbandry sector associated with the production of methane has reduced its environmental impact by half between 1990 and 2014. According to FAO* data, livestock emissions have decreased by 51%, mainly due to the transition to a more specialised livestock farming system.

It should also be remembered that the contribution of various agricultural sectors to greenhouse gas emissions is not only the domain of beef but also of other agri-food products, including fruit and vegetables, which also need to be heated or cooled down as needed, as well as transported, fertilised and cared for in terms of the high quality of products placed on shop shelves.

* Source: http://www.fao.org/faostat/en/#data/GE/visualize

In accordance with Article 12 of Council Directive 93/119/EC, sick or injured animals must be slaughtered on the farm. Legal requirements in this respect are absolute for manufacturers who are trying to deviate from the standards adopted. With high production costs, it is not profitable for breeders to risk allowing the slaughter of sick animals. The production process is also supervised by veterinarians, whose permissions and examinations are necessary for Polish meat to finally reach the tables. In some cases, a sick animal may be allowed to be transported, but only if this does not cause further suffering to the animal. Individual cases of breaking the law are met with criticism of the very environment of cattle breeders who care about the reputation and quality of Polish beef on the domestic and foreign markets.

A report from January 2019 from the slaughterhouse in Kalinowo showed a single facility on the scale of the entire national sector. The material presents a case of illegal slaughter of post-traumatic cattle in one of the Polish facilities. Council Regulation (EC) No 1099/2009 clearly lays down rules for the slaughter of animals for slaughter. These rules were deliberately violated by the owner of the facility and the situation was taken care of by national law enforcement agencies. The incidental situation on a national level was immediately criticised by cattle breeders. It was Polish producers who initiated efforts to tighten the penalties for breaking the regulations. The January publication united the whole environment, committed to constantly improving the quality of the meat produced.

The breaches of slaughter regulations detected in January 2019 were incidental in Poland, but unfortunately they also occur in other markets. Several EU countries have also faced similar cases in the past. In December 2017 and October 2018, a gross violation of production standards was detected in two German slaughterhouses during the killing of animals. In November 2018, recordings from the French slaughterhouse Boischaut were published, where the animals were killed without the required stunning. Following the publication, the largest slaughterhouse customers withdrew from further cooperation. In February 2019, Czech veterinarians discovered an illegal meat factory in Prague. Over a ton of meat was found in the slaughterhouse without the required documents and certificates. In October 2019, the Austrian veterinary authorities discovered that the meat unfit for consumption had been sold to 10 countries, including the Czech Republic and Germany. Out of concern for the quality of the entire market, Polish producers sent an open letter to the Members of the European Parliament with an appeal for the unification of EU regulations based on the changes introduced by the Polish Ministry of Agriculture with the support of industry organisations.

Trade organisations
associating
Polish beef producers
Polski Związek Hodowców i Producentów Bydła Mięsnego (Polish Association of Beef Cattle Breeders and Producers)
Polski Związek Hodowców i Producentów Bydła Mięsnego (Polish Association of Beef Cattle Breeders and Producers)

ul. Rakowiecka 32
02-532 Warsaw,

phone: +48 22 849 19 10

bydlo@bydlo.com.pl

Polskie Zrzeszenie Producentów Bydła Mięsnego (Polish Association of Meat Cattle Producers)
Polskie Zrzeszenie Producentów Bydła Mięsnego (Polish Association of Meat Cattle Producers)

ul. Smulikowskiego 4
00-389 Warsaw,

phone: +48 22 622 09 87

biuro@beef.org.pl

Federacja Związków Pracodawców-Dzierżawców i Właścicieli Rolnych (Federation of the Union of Agricultural Employers and Tenants and Land Owners)
Federacja Związków Pracodawców-Dzierżawców i Właścicieli Rolnych (Federation of the Union of Agricultural Employers and Tenants and Land Owners)

ul. Hoża 66/68
00-682 Warsaw,

phone: +48 22 372 03 49

biuro@federacjarolna.pl

Unia Producentów i Pracodawców Przemysłu Mięsnego (Union of Producers and Employers of the Meat Industry)
Unia Producentów i Pracodawców Przemysłu Mięsnego (Union of Producers and Employers of the Meat Industry)

ul. Aleje Ujazdowskie 18 lok. 16
00-478 Warsaw,

phone: +48 22 696 52 70

biuro@upemi.pl

Stowarzyszenie Rzeźników i Wędliniarzy Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej (Polish Butchers and Cold Meat Producers Association)
Stowarzyszenie Rzeźników i Wędliniarzy Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej (Polish Butchers and Cold Meat Producers Association)

Ul. Miodowa 14
00-246 Warsaw,

phone: +48 22 635 01 84

biuro@srw.org.pl

Polska Federacja Hodowców Bydła i Producentów Mleka (Polish Federation of Cattle Breeders and Dairy Farmers)
Polska Federacja Hodowców Bydła i Producentów Mleka (Polish Federation of Cattle Breeders and Dairy Farmers)

ul. Żurawia 22 lok. 101
00-515 Warsaw,

phone: +48 22 502 33 43

pfhb@pfhb.pl

Związek Polskie Mięso (Polish Meat Association)
Związek Polskie Mięso (Polish Meat Association)

ul. Chałubińskiego 8
00-613 Warsaw,

phone: +48 22 830 16 48

info@polskie-mieso.pl

Legal Acts

on the requirements and the manner of keeping of farm animal species for which protection standards are laid down in the provisions of the European Union

on minimum housing conditions of livestock species other than those whose protection standards are laid down in the provisions of the European Union § 1. The Regulation defines, among others, minimum conditions for keeping cattle with the exception of calves

on the protection of animals

on organisation of breeding and reproduction of farmed animals

on products of animal origin

Polish beef
around the world
Germany France Holland Czech Republic Sweden Austria Greece Spain Israel United Kingdom Portugal Turkey Italy

Project financed by the Milk Promotion Fund